Just thought I’d post a comment as an update here.
I went in tonight to pick up July’s free gift and they only had the one scent available as pictured called “Sharing”. I can’t speak for other locations, but that may be the only scent that they end up giving out - on the plus side though, it smells great!

Also, it would appear that they’ve changed the A-List’s details a bit. In the past they would offer all customers (at least at my location) the free gift plus the chance to save that day with that month’s promotion. Apparently that’s no longer the case. As I stood in line and waited behind another person, I overheard one of the staff explain the A-List to them and continued saying that the free gift was either the free mist or the chance to save 10% off your purchase. Last month there was a ton of discussion regarding the free gift and being offered the 10% discount instead. It looks like the rest of Aerie’s (mine now included) will be following this same guideline so be sure to get in early to claim your free gift!

Mindseye .. Thanks for continuing your monthly posts on Aerie. Nice knowing ahead what the gifts are. This is a good one!